You’ve all heard the buzzwords. High-Def, 1080p, HDMI, Blu-Ray. The list goes on and on. It’s all garbage, nothing more than marketing hype to make you buy into the “magic pill” the entertainment industry is selling you.
“You’re off your rocker, old man,” you say. I can see you rolling your eyes, shaking your head at my old-school stupidity. “Everybody knows HDMI is cool. It’s a one-wire hookup, gives unequalled definition, is the only format that does 1080p, ends world hunger, etc.”
Sadly, all off the reasons in that last sentence are false, except for one. HDMI is truly a 1-wire hookup. Other than that, it provides absolutely no advantages over technology that we already have for end-users. NONE.
“But what about 1080p video?” Guess what? It’s been available in studio-quality component video decks for years. 3-wire component video will easily output 1080p video and higher, with one very important thing missing: the digital copyright protection. This is why even if you buy an HD disk player, it won’t output HD content to the component outputs. That’s why the Playstation 2 and XBox360 won’t play HD video over component… you can only play games in HD unless you use the HDMI connector because analog outputs don’t support Copyright protection (which will become required in 2012).
“What about digital signal quality? Isn’t HDMI better because it’s digital?” In a word, no. You’re limited to very short cable runs, zero fault tolerance, higher cost, and at a true 1080 resolution, you’d have a hard time telling the difference visually. It’s all hype. And as far as sound goes, the digital format is already covered. And what’s more, 90% of the content that is advertised as “1080p” isn’t really, it’s upscaled, interpolated, or antialiased from lower content… but you can only tell the difference when comparing it to true HD 1080p 60hz content, like Discovery’s Planet Earth series which was shot in all 1080p 60 hz.
“Isn’t DRM (Digital Rights Management) good? Isn’t it protecting companies from piracy?” In a word, no. They’d like you to believe “big bad pirates” are stealing all their money. The truth is, DRM has never been about piracy. Over the years many companies have tried to limit the way paying customers use the media they “buy.” Bet you didn’t know this, but 99% of DVD’s sold in stores still, to this day, are encrypted so you can’t play them on an unlicensed device. And they only sell licenses to companies they want to. The only way I can play them on a Linux computer is if I install “legally questionable” CSS decryption software… even though I paid for the DVD. I’m also supposed to buy a CSS DVD player to watch them.
“No big deal,” you might think. “What’s wrong with having to buy a Blu-ray player to watch Blu-rays?” The problem is that it doesn’t stop there. The entertainment industry isn’t interested in stopping piracy, for the most part… they want to control your movie watching experience, from beginning to end, they way they want you to. You want to use a sound clip from a movie you bought to use as a ringtone? Can’t do that. Want to load the movie onto your iPhone to watch? Can’t do that. Want to skip the stupid previews on the disk? Nuh-uh. Want to watch it on a different TV/console in your house, from a media server, at full resolution? Absolutely no way, man. Got an older HD TV that will do 1080 but has no HDMI port? You’re out of luck, chump. Got a computer monitor you want to watch 1080 video on? Has to have special hardware and software to do it with. If you have a digital HD DVR, you better be taking notes… this will affect you in the future.
Do you know why they’re phasing out analog TV, cable, and analog video outputs in general? It’s called “the analog loophole” by the industry, and they hate it. They’re not interested in “giving you the best experience.” For them, DRM is about two things: CONTROL. and MONEY. They are terrified of digital DVRs, and will do whatever they can to lock down that content, in order to be able to charge you for watching it at your leisure. If they can force you to pay to watch what you want, on top of the charge you’re already paying to see it, they love it. They already have rental movies that “expire” and they are going to try to make cable, satellite, and HD disks the same way.
“Aren’t you just being cheap? What’s wrong with just buying a new entertainment system?” This is where I slap my forehead and roll my eyes at you.
I shouldn’t have to buy thousands of dollars of equipment to watch high-def video. If I want to, that’s fine… but it should not be required, when the technology is already cheaply available. You are not paying for HD content… you are playing for the enormous cost of upgrading your entire entertainment center just so it supports the industry’s anti-freedom policies. In the next few months, it will be illegal to build or buy AV equipment that doesn’t support the AACP standards. In the next year or two, it will be illegal to broadcast non-digital content over the airwaves. And in 99% of the TVs you buy today, you’re not getting true 1080p video to it, anyway… it’s limited by the source.
I’m going to fight it as long as I can. I see no need to dole out thousands of dollars just so I can enjoy a movie when I want to watch it. Call me a luddite, call me a retro freak, I don’t care… I don’t like people telling me how I can enjoy my entertainment.

